Proudly Serving Montana

We are your local independent insurance agency. Our mission is to consult and advise you and your family on insurance solutions to protect your assets and minimize risk. We shop multiple carriers to help find our customers reliable and affordable insurance coverage. We can serve your insurance needs, whether for your home, car, or business. We pride ourselves on wonderful customer service and being attentive to your needs.

Sara Nye Agency Office

Convenient & Easy Insurance Solutions

At Sara Nye Agency, we work for you to ensure your needs are properly insured.
With our friendly agents’ assistance, all your questions will be answered. Our customer service extends past your policy. We will guide you through the claims process and make sure your coverage is reviewed. Reach out to our agency today with your insurance questions!

Our Insurance Services














Abinadi SmithAbinadi Smith
22:40 30 May 23
Sara Nye Insurance Agency has been simply the best for getting work done. The team goes above and beyond to help their customers. Being a Custom Residential Construction Company that works across the state and into bordering states is made easier when these professionals are watching out for our better interests. Allowing us to get more work done and have no worries if we are legally and properly covered. They do everything but pay the bill for you! There are plenty of good insurance agents out there, but few great ones. Don’t miss out on a great one, get covered.
Adam BoweAdam Bowe
23:42 25 May 23
Sara and her crew are hands down the best agency around!They respond, get stuff done, don't leave you out to dry, they are trustworthy, and get you the best deal on top of all that. I was an insurance agent myself for a while and they are the best I have found. They have handled several claims for me. They even helped me with a claim they didn't even insure when our "previous" agent gave us a 1- 800 number.They Insure my house, vehicles, toys, and business. I can't speak highly enough about them! Thanks for everything guys!
Leah ClounerLeah Clouner
21:11 25 May 23
Sara and WenDee are amazing! They go the extra mile to make sure you have the best coverage and the best price for your insurance policies. Highly recommend!
Northern HydraulicsNorthern Hydraulics
19:17 25 May 23
I recommend Sara Nye Insurance Agency for your commercial liability, commercial real-estate, and workers comp policy needs. At Northern Hydraulics we have coverage for shop repairs, retail sales, and internet sales. Their professional and courteous team is proactive making sure your risks are covered and keeping premium costs competitive.
Alan ClounerAlan Clouner
15:30 25 May 23
As the owner of Big Sky Lawn Care I moved my business insurance to Sara. They made sure I was covered right and moving my policies easy!


Our agency is licensed in Montana, Idaho, and Washington.

Sara Nye Agency


  • Monday-Thursday: 9:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • Friday: 9:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • Weekends & Evenings: By Appointment
Summit States Logo
Farmer Union Logo
Refer-a-friend 2